 |
Book Reviews of The Atlas of Middle-Earth (Revised Edition)Book Review: necessity for Tolkien fans Summary: 5 Stars
When reading Lord of the Rings or other Tolkien works like the Silmarillion, many readers (including myself) find the vastness of it all very difficult. It's hard to remember which mountains were where, who lived in what place, and when various peoples moved. Despite a few inaccuracies, this atlas is an invaluable resource, especially for geography buffs. It provides great detail in all areas. Even the size and direction of advancing armies is noted, lending the whole saga an even more "historical" feel. Just another great resource that brings the classic Tolkien mythology to life!
Book Review: superb Summary: 5 Stars
i had the original edition atlas (published early 1980's) with me when i re-read the hobbit and LOTR trilogy last winter. The atlas provides a visual aid that made it easier for me to participate imaginatively in the progress of the stories. it is also very helpful when reading the silmarillion and other tolkien works.i agree with the criticism about general maps at times being too separated from detailed maps. i spent a lot of time flipping pages back and forth and kept two or three book marks in place at one time. ...
Book Review: THE ATLAS IS GOOD TO USE WHILE READING THE BOOK. Summary: 5 Stars
THIS ATLAS HAS MANY GOOD THINGS TO LOOK AT AND A LOT OF USEFUL INFORMATION. I HAVE LOOKED AT ALL THE MAPS AND READ SOME OF THE BOOK. IT TELLS HOW FAR THEY WENT IN ONE DAY AND ANY IMPORTANT THINGS THAT HAPPENED, ALONG WITH GREAT MAPS. AND THE BATTLE MAPS ARE WONDERFUL WITH DETAILS ABOUT HOW MANY MEN,ELVES,ORCS ECT FOR EVERY BATTLE!! IF YOU WANT A DETAILED MAP ALL ABOUT THE JOURNEY, THEN GET THIS BOOK IT IS VERY HELPFUL IN VISUALIZING THE WORLD. TheLoneRoman2002
Book Review: Perfect Gift for a Tolkin-ite Summary: 5 Stars
I specifically ordered this book for a friend of mine who is REALLY in not only Lord of the Rings but everything that has to do with that series. He can talk small pieces of information like a skilled essayist and will deftly argue minutae (sp?) with cliff notes as it were to back it up.
When I found out he lost this book in a house fire, I knew he'd appreciate it back. He was.
Hope that helps...spelling/grammar not with standing.
Book Review: A must have! Summary: 5 Stars
These maps cover all of Tolkien's world. An absolute must have to truly understand "where's what" in the Lord of the Rings and the Hobbit. Fonstad does an exceptional job at laying out not just maps, but history, battles, geography, climate, ect. This book covers the very beginnings of Tolkein's world, through Middle Earth, and up to the age of men. A very remarkable work.
More Customer Reviews: First Review 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
|
 |
|
|
|