Men Against Fire: The Problem of Battle Command

Men Against Fire: The Problem of Battle Command
by S.L. A. Marshall

Men Against Fire: The Problem of Battle Command
List Price: $19.95
Our Price: $12.00
You Save: $7.95 (40%)
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Buy Used: from $5.62 (click here)
Category: Book
See more book details and other editions


(Click here)
Buy this book at online book store in your country
Canada | UK | Germany | France

Book Summary Information

Author: S.L. A. Marshall
Edition: Paperback
Audio: English (Unknown); English (Original Language); English (Published)
Published: 2000-09-15
ISBN: 0806132809
Number of pages: 224
Publisher: University of Oklahoma Press

Book Reviews of Men Against Fire: The Problem of Battle Command

Book Review: S.L.A. Marshall's Controversial Revelation
Summary: 5 Stars

Col. Samuel Lyman Atwood Marshall's, former chief combat historian Central Pacific (1943) and chief historian European Theatre of Operations (1945), 1947 book, Men Against Fire: The Problem of Battle Command, predicted that infantry would be essential in future conflicts despite the era's belief that machine-based warfare and atomic super weapons would render traditional warfare obsolete.

Marshall criticized 1940's doctrine as having adapting 20th century weapons to 18th century tactics and postulated that the most important factor in combat is the volume of lethal fire that can be directed onto the enemy. Thus all movement should be made with the intent of maximizing fire output. Logically, any troop refusing to fire at the enemy reduces the maximum achievable fire output. Marshall called the ratio of firers to non-firers, the Ratio of Fire. Marshall stated only 15 to 25 percent of individual infantry riflemen in close contact with the enemy would actually shoot unless compelled by an officer standing over them. Marshall felt the ratio of fire equation could be maximized by improving unit cohesion and by providing realistic training to educate soldiers on what physical and psychological conditions to expect on the battlefield.

Chapter 1, "The Illusion of Power," highlights the need to integrate infantry into strategic plans. Examples illustrate how shortages in infantry reserves nearly crippled operations in Europe after D-Day. In Chapter 2, "On Future War," Marshall makes a projection as to the nature of future international warfare and mutual destruction. Projections echo the Cold War, but fail thereafter. Modern counterinsurgency roles and pinpoint strike capabilities were beyond Marshall's comprehension.

In Chapter 3, "Man on the Battlefield," Marshall explores battlefield neurosis. Differences between Hollywood's romanticized versions of combat and reality are examined and convincing explanations are offered as to how this affects soldiers fulfilling responsibilities on the battlefield. Chapter 4, "Combat Isolation," offers a powerful description of the phenomenon of battlefield isolation, the psychological experience that occurs when soldiers lose sight contact of comrades while under fire, and its effect on fighting spirit.

In Chapter 5, "Ratio of Fire," Marshall explains the concept of Ratio of Fire... clearly leaving no room for debate as to the importance of maintaining a high ratio of fire. However, Marshall fails to provide any collaborating documentation anywhere in Men Against Fire, to include a single named witness, to substantiate his statistics. Chapter 6, "Fire as the Cure," advances a non-traditional idea that even non-firing soldiers fulfill useful battlefield functions by reducing isolation, maintaining momentum, and holding ground as non-firers are reportedly no more likely to give ground than firers. The presence of non-firers is still demoralizing to enemies.

Chapter 7, "The Multiples of Information," insightfully explores the confusion inherent in military communications. The importance of small unit communications is clearly defined and concise explanations are offered as to why communications laterally disintegrate. Chapter 8, "The Riddle of Command," then explores the relationship between intelligence flowing rearward, and logistics and orders flowing forward. Common obstacles preventing each level of the command structure from receiving critical information are explored.

Chapter 9, "Tactical Cohesion," masterfully describes the familiarization process by which units become experienced in functioning under battle conditions. Verbal communication is stressed as critical in close combat and building unit cohesion. Chapter 10, "Why Men Fight," strongly emphasizes verbal communication as the primary means of initiating action, maintaining discipline and controlling emotion.

Chapter 11, "The Aggressive Will," quantifies the fighting spirit and makes a strong connection between morale and the Army's willingness to provide for soldier welfare. Chapter 12, "Men Under Fire," illustrates how combat morale ebbs and flows. Adaptable leaders must fit the situation and still focus on responsibilities.

Chapter 13, "Footnote to History," stands alone and applauds the decision to chronicle the fighting line as weapons alone are valueless.

Men Against Fire is very insightful. I highly recommend it anyone wanting to comprehend the psychological factors affecting infantry in close combat. Ratio of fire was very controversial in 1947, as it is today. The Army examined the issue and other evidence existed to support Marshall. French Col. Ardant du Picq made similar observations in Battle Studies in 1870 and Civil War battles historically showed disproportionate numbers of misses. The Army made dramatic changes to its training doctrine, adapting Marshall's recommendations.

Modern evidence suggests that Marshall may have indeed invented the specific numbers quoted in his ratio of fire statistics to add credibility to his claim, though evidence suggests he did genuinely seem to believe that the ratio of fire issue was very real.

Summary of Men Against Fire: The Problem of Battle Command

S.L.A. "Slam" Marshall was a veteran of World War I and a combat historian during World War II. He startled the military and civilian world in 1947 by announcing that, in an average infantry company, no more than one in four soldiers actually fired their weapons while in contact with the enemy. His contention was based on interviews he conducted immediately after combat in both the European and Pacific theaters of World War II.

To remedy the gunfire imbalance he proposed changes to infantry training designed to ensure that American soldiers in future wars brought more fire upon the enemy. His studies during the Korean War showed that the ratio of fire and more than doubled since World War II.


United States Books

Book Subjects
Most talked about in United States Books
An Honorable Defeat: The Last Days of the Confederate Government ImageAn Honorable Defeat: The Last Days of the Confederate Government
by William C. Davis
Houghton Mifflin Harcourt; Published: 2001-06-04; Hardcover; Book
Best price: $5.50
Price in other shops: $30.00
Bombs Away: The Story of a Bomber Team (Penguin Classics) ImageBombs Away: The Story of a Bomber Team (Penguin Classics)
by John Steinbeck
Penguin Classics; Published: 2009-07-08; Paperback; Book
Best price: $7.98
Price in other shops: $15.00
The Naval Aristocracy: The Golden Age of Annapolis and the Emergence of Modern American Navalism ImageThe Naval Aristocracy: The Golden Age of Annapolis and the Emergence of Modern American Navalism
by Peter Karsten
Free Press; Published: 1972-05; Hardcover; Book
Best price: $172.69
The Complete Idiot's Guide to the U.S. Special Ops Forces ImageThe Complete Idiot's Guide to the U.S. Special Ops Forces
by Marc Cerasini
Alpha; Published: 2002-04-15; Paperback; Book
Best price: $4.08
Price in other shops: $18.95
Roberts Ridge: A Story of Courage and Sacrifice on Takur Ghar Mountain, Afghanistan ImageRoberts Ridge: A Story of Courage and Sacrifice on Takur Ghar Mountain, Afghanistan
by Malcolm MacPherson
Delacorte Press; Published: 2005-08-30; Hardcover; Book
Best price: $57.88
Flyboys: A True Story of Courage ImageFlyboys: A True Story of Courage
by James Bradley
Little, Brown and Company; Published: 2003-09; Hardcover; Book
Best price: $29.85
Price in other shops: $42.00
Transformation Under Fire: Revolutionizing How America Fights ImageTransformation Under Fire: Revolutionizing How America Fights
by Douglas A. Macgregor
Praeger; Published: 2008-10-30; Paperback; Book
Best price: $25.00
Fiasco: The American Military Adventure in Iraq, 2003 to 2005 ImageFiasco: The American Military Adventure in Iraq, 2003 to 2005
by Thomas E. Ricks
Penguin (Non-Classics); Published: 2007-07-31; Paperback; Book
Best price: $4.59
Price in other shops: $16.00
Gettysburg: A Testing of Courage ImageGettysburg: A Testing of Courage
by Noah Andre Trudeau
Harper Perennial; Published: 2003-05-27; Paperback; Book
Best price: $9.98
Price in other shops: $18.99
Blind Man's Bluff: The Untold Story of American Submarine Espionage ImageBlind Man's Bluff: The Untold Story of American Submarine Espionage
by Sherry Sontag, Christopher Drew, Annette Lawrence Drew
HarperTorch; Published: 1999-10-06; Mass Market Paperback; Book
Best price: $5.95
Price in other shops: $7.99
Similar Books and other products
The Mission, The Men, and Me: Lessons from a Former Delta Force Commander ImageThe Mission, The Men, and Me: Lessons from a Former Delta Force Commander
by Pete Blaber
Berkley Hardcover; Published: 2008-12-02; Hardcover; Book
Best price: $6.95
Price in other shops: $25.95
First to Fight: An Inside View of the U.S. Marine Corps (Bluejacket Books) ImageFirst to Fight: An Inside View of the U.S. Marine Corps (Bluejacket Books)
by Victor H. Krulak
Naval Inst Pr; Published: 1999-04; Paperback; Book
Best price: $11.95
Price in other shops: $19.95
The Mission, The Men, and Me: Lessons from a Former Delta Force Commander ImageThe Mission, The Men, and Me: Lessons from a Former Delta Force Commander
by Pete Blaber
Berkley Trade; Published: 2010-09-07; Paperback; Book
Best price: $8.52
Price in other shops: $15.00
Soldiers of God: With Islamic Warriors in Afghanistan and Pakistan ImageSoldiers of God: With Islamic Warriors in Afghanistan and Pakistan
by Robert D. Kaplan
Vintage; Published: 2001-11; Paperback; Book
Best price: $2.96
Price in other shops: $16.00
The Soldier's Load and the Mobility of a Nation ImageThe Soldier's Load and the Mobility of a Nation
by S. L. A. Marshall
Marine Corp Assn Bookstore; Published: 1980-06; Paperback; Book
Best price: $20.76
Battle Leadership ImageBattle Leadership
by Adolf Von Schell
Marine Corp Assn Bookstore; Published: 1987-06; Paperback; Book
Best price: $9.95
Leadership: The Warrior's Art ImageLeadership: The Warrior's Art
Army War College Foundation Press; Published: 2001-06-01; Paperback; Book
Best price: $11.24
Price in other shops: $21.95
The Village ImageThe Village
by Bing West
Pocket Books; Published: 2002-12-31; Mass Market Paperback; Book
Best price: $3.30
Price in other shops: $7.99
On Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society ImageOn Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society
by Dave Grossman
Back Bay Books; Published: 2009-06-22; Paperback; Book
Best price: $9.27
Price in other shops: $16.99
Acts of War: Behavior of Men in Battle ImageActs of War: Behavior of Men in Battle
by Richard Holmes
Free Press; Published: 1989-08-04; Paperback; Book
Best price: $15.97
Price in other shops: $20.50
Book store. Illustrated catalog of books on different categories