Jimi Hendrix : The Man, the Magic, the Truth by Sharon Lawrence
|
Our Price: $116.58 Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $7.35 (click here) Category: Book See more book details and other editions |
|---|
Book Reviews of Jimi Hendrix : The Man, the Magic, the Truth
Book Review: Wonderful Insight--Poor Speculation
Summary: 5 Stars
It was very interesting reading this book because of several reasons: The narration is excellently depicted, very good main ideas were achieved, and most importantly, the myth of Jimi's death. Many people subscribe to the suicide notion. If it helps you sleep at night, more power to you. With so much research done, I was surprised that the author didn't have the courage to touch on how Jimi Hendrix actually died. It is much deeper than suicide or drug overdose.
President Nixon contracted the Mafia to do the hit on Hendrix on the basis that a black musician was gaining so much respect in the entertainment industry which ironically was partially controlled by the mob anyway. Hendrix was promoted by factions of the mob as DJ's were held at gunpoint and forced to play Jimi's records.
Jimi let the success get to his head and he began to forget who got him the fame and money: the mob. Jimi ignored the unwritten contract that he shared with the Italians. The decision to murder Jimi Hendrix was made at a meeting involving Mafia bosses from both New York as well as Chicago and the current president Richard Nixon two blocks away from the warehouse in which the Valentine's Day Massacre took place.
For this reason, I rate this book at five stars although accuracy of historical data researched is nonexistent.
Book Review: I had credibility problems with this book also
Summary: 3 Stars
Especially with her contention that Jimi committed suicide. Jimi's closest companions during the European tour - Mitch, Billy Cox, roadie Eric Barrett, etc contend that Jimi was in great spirits weeks before his death, especially with regards to Electric Lady Studios. Sure, he had all the hangers-on, financial, and manager crap, but he just didn't sound suicidal.
I liked hearing the more personal things, such as who Jimi's favorite actors were (Brando, James Dean), [...]
Book Review: Long on drama, woefully short on credibility
Summary: 2 Stars
While I applaud Ms. Lawrence for educating fans on the gross injustices within the Hendrix family and for having a commendable understanding of Janie Hendrix's psychological make up that is lost even on many who are within her orbit, there are some very serious credibility problems here.
While even the idle Hendrix fan knows Jimi was born in King County Hospital, (Now Harbor View) Lawrence states he was born at the home of a family friend.(Ouch) Jimi is quoted allegedly verbatum throughout the book but from some alledged tapes of interviews that no one has seen or heard and that Lawrence conveniently plans on destroying so 'no one can profit from them'.Meanwhile cigarette packs (yes, cigarette packs) and necklaces are being sold via ebay or to private collectors allegedly having belonged to Hendrix ,siting Ms. Lawrence as the previous owner and source of authenticity.
At one point she aledgedly quotes Hendrix as saying:
"The LSD passed around San Francisco was a fabulous discovery for me, I'd taken acid in London but...."
Aside from Jimi's use of the word 'fabulous' being at best incredulous, the fact that Hendrix had already tried LSD in New York in 1996 before going to England and subsequently Monterey is common knowledge among afficianados and again makes all of these alledged direct quotes questionable. Those of you who have listened to and read the hundreds of hours of interviews available through collectors, official releases and press clippings will also find some of the wording of these alledged quotes that the book, and the credibility of it's author are based on, extremely suspect. At one point Ms. Lawrence even offers an aledged quote from Hendrix's mother who passed away in 1958:
"Jimi baby" she told her son "I have to escape this"
While quotes like this can illicit an emotional response
from the average reader,they are clearly fictional. Throughout the book people close to Jimi are referenced but very sparsely quoted, if at all. I shared the recount of Jimi's trip to Berkeley as a small child (Pg.5) with Jimi's aunt Delores and she laughed openly and wondered aloud where people come up with these stories. This from a woman who was actually there and involved in planning said trip. While making a reference to Ernestine Benson and misstakenly referring to her husband Cornel as "Bill" , Lawrence again allegedly quotes Hendrix in lieu of an actual interview with the Benson's who are both still living and have incredible first hand insights having lived with the Hendrix's.
Lawrence's assertion that Hendrix committed suicide simply because his journal was left out is no less ridiculous than Jimi's adopted stepsister Janie's claim that Jimi didn't OD. Lawrence then stops just short of gleefully giving herself credit for Monika's suicide, but the jist is clear. This book is more than a bit narcissistic with Lawrence lauding herself as much as she does her subject. While proclaiming herself to be a close confident of Hendrix' the general consensus is that she wasn't around that much, if people even know who she is at all.
For a much more well researched and credible look into Jimi's life read Electric Gypsy or even more so , the new book Room Full Of Mirrors by Charles Cross. The Man, The Magic, The Truth, while very dramatic, is rife with glaring inaccuracies and is for the most part a novel about the author and her subject, not a biography or a reliable historical record. Unless these alledged tapes that are widely quoted throughout the entire book are made available, their legitimacy and the legitimacy of the book will forever be questioned.
Ray Rae Goldman
Archivist/Historian
James Marshall Hendrix Foundation
Book Review: Hendrix: The Man, The Magic, ect. is amazing!
Summary: 5 Stars
This book is absolutely wonderful! It provides a factful insight a Jimi Hendrix's life. Shannon Lawrence is the best person to write a book about Hendrix. I recommend it to any true Jimi Hendrix fan!!!Book Review: Hendrix fan since 1968
Summary: 5 Stars
Ms. Lawrence' book tells the story a longtime Hendrix fan has known but not known for sure until now. I cried the day he died and tears filled my eyes as I read the last words of this book. I recently went to Renton to Jimi's gravesite, and I only wish I had known of this book prior to my trip, it would've given me a different prespective relative to my visit. Thank you Ms. Lawrence for answering questions not answered for so long and helping the world to know what a kind, loving and gentle man Jimi was.