 |
Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan by Herbert P. Bix
Book Summary InformationAuthor: Herbert P. Bix Edition: Paperback Audio: English (Unknown); English (Original Language); English (Published) Published: 2001-09-04 ISBN: 0060931302 Number of pages: 832 Publisher: Harper Perennial
Book Reviews of Hirohito and the Making of Modern JapanBook Review: I was crushed! Summary: 5 Stars
I read this book on Hirohito and found it to be one of the most interesting books I've read in a long time. Note: this book is not too easy to get into however for students of Japan it's well worth the investment. It took me about 300 pages of book before I started getting really interested in this story.
For me, the most interesting thing was that this book changed my ideas of Japan and Hirohito in WWII. I believed previously that Hirohito was mislead by a military junta of men that controlled and somewhat threatened him. I had believed that Hirohito had little influence over the Japanese military. I used to explain to my friends how Hirohito was a great hero of mine because, when Japan was getting destroyed by the United States, he, at great personal risk to himself, stepped up from the shadows and told Japan to surrender. I believed that he was a brave man for taking the risk that his military generals and admirals would have him killed over such a surrender and that he was surrendering to avoid the complete destruction of the Japanese people.
This book however showed me what was a very different story. It seems to say that Hirohito wanted to emulate the greatness and glory of Japan's defeat of Russia. The book explains that Hirohito was very much involved and in control as Japan tried to make her place in the world of the 20th century. And the book puts a big part of the blame for Japan's WWII role and atrocities on Hirohito himself. For example, the book says, if I remember correctly, that Hirohito's relatives in the military were telling him of the atrocities in China and that Hirohito did little to nothing to stop them. Next, the book says, as Japan's defeat was nigh and American bombers were destroying all of Japan's cities with abandon, Hirohito cut a deal with McArthur to save the throne for himself and Japan. Hirohito agreed to tell the Japanese military to surrender to the Americans if McArthur would, in turn, agree to help arrange a coverup for the Emperor. Hirohito agreed to this because he knew the U.S. would immediately depose him as Emperor and probably rid the country of the position of Emperor. The coverup involved re-telling the story of how the war came about. It named the military junta as the guilty party and spared the Emperor for his complicity in the American occupation of Japan and also saved the Japanese royal family. The Americans, as part of the agreement, told the Japanese people and the rest of the world that the Emperor was actually a victim of this Japanese military "coup de etat".
I was quite crushed that Hirohito's decision to surrender to the Americans was not a magnanimous gesture to save his people, but rather a self-interested decision to save his own skin and his royal family. All things considered, this book told me a story that I will never forget.
Summary of Hirohito and the Making of Modern JapanWinner of the Pulitzer PrizeIn this groundbreaking biography of the Japanese emperor Hirohito, Herbert P. Bix offers the first complete, unvarnished look at the enigmatic leader whose sixty-three-year reign ushered Japan into the modern world. Never before has the full life of this controversial figure been revealed with such clarity and vividness. Bix shows what it was like to be trained from birth for a lone position at the apex of the nation's political hierarchy and as a revered symbol of divine status. Influenced by an unusual combination of the Japanese imperial tradition and a modern scientific worldview, the young emperor gradually evolves into his preeminent role, aligning himself with the growing ultranationalist movement, perpetuating a cult of religious emperor worship, resisting attempts to curb his power, and all the while burnishing his image as a reluctant, passive monarch. Here we see Hirohito as he truly was: a man of strong will and real authority. Supported by a vast array of previously untapped primary documents, Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan is perhaps most illuminating in lifting the veil on the mythology surrounding the emperor's impact on the world stage. Focusing closely on Hirohito's interactions with his advisers and successive Japanese governments, Bix sheds new light on the causes of the China War in 1937 and the start of the Asia-Pacific War in 1941. And while conventional wisdom has had it that the nation's increasing foreign aggression was driven and maintained not by the emperor but by an elite group of Japanese militarists, the reality, as witnessed here, is quite different. Bix documents in detail the strong, decisive role Hirohito played in wartime operations, from the takeover of Manchuria in 1931 through the attack on Pearl Harbor and ultimately the fateful decision in 1945 to accede to an unconditional surrender. In fact, the emperor stubbornly prolonged the war effort and then used the horrifying bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, together with the Soviet entrance into the war, as his exit strategy from a no-win situation. From the moment of capitulation, we see how American and Japanese leaders moved to justify the retention of Hirohito as emperor by whitewashing his wartime role and reshaping the historical consciousness of the Japanese people. The key to this strategy was Hirohito's alliance with General MacArthur, who helped him maintain his stature and shed his militaristic image, while MacArthur used the emperor as a figurehead to assist him in converting Japan into a peaceful nation. Their partnership ensured that the emperor's image would loom large over the postwar years and later decades, as Japan began to make its way in the modern age and struggled -- as it still does -- to come to terms with its past. Until the very end of a career that embodied the conflicting aims of Japan's development as a nation, Hirohito remained preoccupied with politics and with his place in history. Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan provides the definitive account of his rich life and legacy. Meticulously researched and utterly engaging, this book is proof that the history of twentieth-century Japan cannot be understood apart from the life of its most remarkable and enduring leader. To many, Emperor Hirohito of Japan is remembered as a helpless figurehead during Japan's wars with China and the U.S. According to the received wisdom, he knew nothing of the plan to bomb Pearl Harbor and had no power to stop atrocities like the Rape of Nanking. The emperor was the mild-mannered little man who traipsed with Mickey Mouse in Disneyland and who brought peace through surrender, certainly not "one of the most disingenuous persons ever to occupy the modern throne." Herbert Bix's charged political biography, however, argues that such accepted beliefs are myths and misrepresentations spun by both Japanese and Americans to protect the emperor from indictment. Since Hirohito's death in 1989, hundreds of documents, diaries, and scholarly studies have been published (and subsequently ignored) in Japan. Historian Bix used these sources to develop this shocking and nuanced portrait of a man far more shrewd, activist, and energetic than previously thought. Caught up in the fever of territorial expansion, Hirohito was the force that animated the war system, who, acting fully as a military leader and head of state, encouraged the belligerency of his people and pursued the war to its disastrous conclusion. To the very end, Hirohito refused to acknowledge any responsibility for his role in the death of millions as well as the brutalities inflicted by his forces in China, Korea, and the Philippines. In fact, he worked with none other than General MacArthur to select his fall guys and fix testimony at the Tokyo War Crimes Trials--the emperor trying to protect the throne at all cost, the U.S. acting to ensure control of the Japanese population and the military by retaining Hirohito as a figurehead. Not surprisingly, this hefty work of scholarship is making waves, as Americans and Japanese reconsider their roles in WWII and its aftermath. By placing Hirohito back in the center of the picture and puncturing the myths that surround him, Bix has effectively asked the Japanese to come out of their half-century repression of the past and face their wartime responsibility. Without doing so, he implies, the monarchy will forever impede the development of democracy. For those interested in Japan's wartime past and its influence on the present, this is fascinating, if lengthy, reading. --Lesley Reed
|
 |