 |
Colossus: The Rise and Fall of the American Empire by Niall Ferguson
Book Summary InformationAuthor: Niall Ferguson Edition: Paperback Audio: English (Unknown); English (Original Language); English (Published) Published: 2005-03-29 ISBN: 0143034790 Number of pages: 416 Publisher: Penguin (Non-Classics)
Book Reviews of Colossus: The Rise and Fall of the American EmpireBook Review: Another must-read from the great contrarian Summary: 5 Stars
This excellent and thought-provoking book is a companion and follow-on to Professor Ferguson's best-selling and critically acclaimed `Empire.' Whereas `Empire' was an examination of the historical legacy of the British Empire, `Colossus' brings the USA and its role in the world under the spotlight. Ferguson is of course not the first academic writer to do this but he does bring an original and radical perspective to the subject.
The fundamentals of Professor Ferguson's thesis are that the USA is, and has been for some 50 years, an `Empire in Denial.' His controversial and `politically incorrect' perspective is that there is nothing wrong with an empire, per se: that if one examines human history empires have been the norm not the exception; that the 19th century invention of the `nation state' is artificial and flawed, and has demonstrably led to an unnecessary level of poverty, to petty tyrannies and internecine tribal warfare, to `failed states' and misery for millions. He also sees the UN as chronically under-funded with a General Assembly dominated largely by unelected despots, an impotent paper tiger which can not and will not for the foreseeable future do anything effective to keep global peace.
In the first half of the book, the author gives a good overview of the history of the USA and its de-facto empire-building tendencies: its continental expansion westwards, wars against Spain and Mexico, adventures in The Philippines and in various parts of Latin America, and how it came to colonise parts of the Pacific region and gain military bases around the globe.
In the present day (the book was written in 2004) Ferguson sees the USA as an empire in all but name because of, among other things:
1. Complete dominance in military power with a global reach unlikely to be matched by any other state or combination of states in the foreseeable future, with a qualitative technological supremacy which makes it unique in human history
2. Economic and political power not so obviously complete or unchallenged as its military dominance but nevertheless significant, challenged only by a politically weak, uncertain and incompletely unified EU & a not yet developed economic superpower in China
3. Due to the international media power of Hollywood in particular and US popular culture in general, plus the world dominance of the English language, the USA is THE globally-dominant cultural superpower
Ferguson sees the current 180-plus independent and disparate nation states making up the geopolitical map as an inherently unstable and unsustainable model which results in permanent warfare, instability and inequities. His thesis is that because Europe, the only possible alternative, is insufficiently united and demonstrably lacks the political will, the USA has to act as global policeman simply because no-one else will exercise the responsibility. However the author sees the USA as de-facto global superpower to be disappointing with poor results, and points to several inherent weaknesses which make it ill-suited to exercising its global responsibilities:
1. Chronic fiscal indebtedness due mainly to federal spending on Medicare and other welfare commitments - >US$50 trillion and rising
2. Addiction to consumerism at any price leading to a chronic imbalance of trade
3. The manifest unwillingness of American citizens to take up their global responsibilities and serve abroad
4. A chronic national myopic `attention deficit' - let's get in and bomb, then get the troops out quickly, never mind about clearing up the mess or making a long-term commitment to ensure stability
The author makes the case that a global hegemon - `Pax Romana' in the ancient world or `Pax Britannica' in the 1800s - is A Good Thing for global stability. These former empires brought rule of law, stable government and huge investment to the regions under their control. In contrast, the recent era of US geo-political dominance has seen the `developing world' starved of investment with corrupt, despotic and kleptocratic governments indulged and tolerated; the erosion of human rights, poverty and bankruptcy for millions all in the name of `independence' and `sovereignty.'
Ferguson sees the primary causes of this woeful state of affairs to be a reluctance on the part of US policy makers, and the population as a whole, to get involved. He cites examples in the mid-20th century of the US making long-term commitments to Germany and Japan following WW2 and to South Korea in the 1950s, resulting eventually in free, democratic and prosperous nations with respect for human rights and good, non-corrupt governments, net contributors to the world. However these three examples have been exceptions: the USA has subsequently been hyper-sensitive about being seen as `imperialist' and in most cases does not follow-through its interventions with sufficient commitment or thoroughness to see a worthwhile result.
So in summary, Ferguson's view is that policy-makers in the USA might learn from the British example and impose a new global order for the 21st century by force if necessary rather than let the world continue to live in factional instability and chaos, populated by too many bankrupt failed states and aid-beggars. He sees only the USA as capable of implementing such a New World Order dominated by free democratic institutions and prosperity due to its military, political and economic power and its global reach.
`Colossus' is a rewarding, intelligent and original thesis offering a new perspective on the responsibilities of being a global superpower. It opens up interesting discussions on power structures and slays a few sacred cows (like the myopic ideological belief that Empire is a bad thing, period - `compared to what?' he asks). Even if you find yourself disagreeing with all or part of the author's thesis, it's healthy to have the debate and think out of the box for a change.
`Colossus' is highly recommended by this reviewer, especially to the more intelligent reader who welcomes new and original thought and is not afraid to have his preconceptions challenged by new ideas.
Summary of Colossus: The Rise and Fall of the American EmpireIs America an empire? Certainly not, according to our government. Despite the conquest of two sovereign states in as many years, despite the presence of more than 750 military installations in two thirds of the world?s countries and despite his stated intention "to extend the benefits of freedom...to every corner of the world," George W. Bush maintains that "America has never been an empire." "We don?t seek empires," insists Defense Secretary Rumsfeld. "We?re not imperialistic." Nonsense, says Niall Ferguson. In Colossus he argues that in both military and economic terms America is nothing less than the most powerful empire the world has ever seen. Just like the British Empire a century ago, the United States aspires to globalize free markets, the rule of law, and representative government. In theory it?s a good project, says Ferguson. Yet Americans shy away from the long-term commitments of manpower and money that are indispensable if rogue regimes and failed states really are to be changed for the better. Ours, he argues, is an empire with an attention deficit disorder, imposing ever more unrealistic timescales on its overseas interventions. Worse, it?s an empire in denial?a hyperpower that simply refuses to admit the scale of its global responsibilities. And the negative consequences will be felt at home as well as abroad. In an alarmingly persuasive final chapter Ferguson warns that this chronic myopia also applies to our domestic responsibilities. When overstretch comes, he warns, it will come from within?and it will reveal that more than just the feet of the American colossus is made of clay. "The United States today is an empire?but a peculiar kind of empire," writes Niall Ferguson. Despite overwhelming military, economic, and cultural dominance, America has had a difficult time imposing its will on other nations, mostly because the country is uncomfortable with imperialism and thus unable to use this power most effectively and decisively. The origin of this attitude and its persistence is a principal theme of this thought-provoking book, including how domestic politics affects foreign policy, whether it is politicians worried about the next election or citizens who "like Social Security more than national security." Ferguson, a British historian, has no objection to an American empire, as long as it is a liberal one actively underwriting the free exchange of goods, labor, and capital. Further, he writes that "empire is more necessary in the twenty-first century than ever before" as a means to "contain epidemics, depose tyrants, end local wars and eradicate terrorist organizations." The sooner America embraces this role and acts on it confidently, the better. Ferguson contrasts this persistent anti-imperialistic urge with the attitude held by the British Empire and suggests that America has much to learn from that model if it is to achieve its stated foreign policy objectives of spreading social freedom, democracy, development, and the free market to the world. He suggests that the U.S. must be willing to send money, civilians, and troops for a sustained period of time to troubled spots if there is to be real change?as in Japan and Germany after World War II--an idea that many American citizens and leaders now find repulsive. Rather than devoting limited resources and striving to get complex jobs done in a rush, Americans must be willing to integrate themselves into a foreign culture until a full Americanization has occurred, he writes. Overall, a trenchant examination of a uniquely American dilemma and its implications for the rest of the world. --Shawn Carkonen
|
 |
The Cold War: A Global History With Documentsby Edward H. Judge Prentice Hall College Div; Published: 2012-09; Paperback; BookBest price: $60.00
Why America Fights: Patriotism and War Propaganda from the Philippines to Iraqby Susan A. Brewer Oxford University Press, USA; Published: 2011-03-09; Paperback; BookBest price: $12.45Price in other shops: $21.95
Advancing the Ball: Race, Reformation, and the Quest for Equal Coaching Opportunity in the NFL (Law and Current Events Masters)by N. Jeremi Duru Oxford University Press, USA; Published: 2011-01-07; Hardcover; BookBest price: $14.16Price in other shops: $24.95
A History of Our Time: Readings on Postwar AmericaOxford University Press, USA; Published: 2007-04-13; Paperback; BookBest price: $38.94Price in other shops: $49.95
Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States, George W. Bush, 2001, Bk. 1, January 20 to June 30, 2001by George W. Bush National Archives and Records Administra; Published: 2003-05-21; Hardcover; BookBest price: $75.00
The Real State of America Atlas: Mapping the Myths and Truths of the United Statesby Cynthia Enloe, Joni Seager Penguin (Non-Classics); Published: 2011-07-26; Paperback; BookBest price: $12.49Price in other shops: $22.00
Torture Team: Uncovering War Crimes in the Land of the Free. Philippe Sandsby Philippe Sands Penguin Books; Published: 2009-05; Paperback; BookBest price: $35.00
One Nation, After All : What Americans Really Think About God, Country, Family, Racism, Welfare, Immigration, Homosexuality, Work, The Right, The Left and Each Otherby Alan Wolfe Penguin (Non-Classics); Published: 1999-03-01; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $3.59Price in other shops: $13.95
Freedom Is Not Enough: The Moynihan Report and America's Struggle over Black Family Life--from LBJ to Obamaby James T. Patterson Basic Books; Published: 2010-05-04; Hardcover; BookBest price: $3.37Price in other shops: $26.95
When Everything Changed: The Amazing Journey of American Women from 1960 to the Presentby Gail Collins Little, Brown and Company; Published: 2009-10-14; Hardcover; BookBest price: $2.42Price in other shops: $27.99
|
|