Collage City by Colin Rowe, Fred Koetter
|
List Price: Our Price: $24.30 You Save: $2.70 (10%) Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Used: from $15.00 (click here) Category: Book See more book details and other editions |
|---|
Book Reviews of Collage City
Book Review: Difficult, opaque, frustrating, but important
Summary: 4 Stars
I am a second-generation Rowe disciple, I guess. I studied with a Rowe acolyte in graduate school and worked with co-author Fred Koetter in an urban design studio. Without the efforts these teachers have made to bring Rowe's ideas to urban design students, they may well have been neglected, because Collage City is a mess. It is badly marred by dense thickets of poorly-edited, idiosyncratic prose. It was one of the more frustrating books I had to read in school, but I'm glad it was required, because the close readings uncovered real gems of theory. Rowe reintroduced the complexities and possibilities of art into urban design right at the peak of Modernism's influence. Architecture was still in the thrall of La Ville Radieuse and socialist-utopian projects that aimed to simplify and disinfect cities. Jane Jacobs saw the social perils of these projects, Colin Rowe saw the architectural perils. His critique of the Modern project was among the most powerful, and among the least cogent. Still, though it requires some serious digging in prose-mud, the gems are there and worth the search. I recommend this book for graduate-level urban theorists or serious urban design students.
But there are more accessible urban design primers: Aldo Rossi, et al, The Architecture of the City, for example, covers much of the same ground Rowe so spottily tilled [except where Eisenman is involved in the book: he is a worse prose-stylist than Rowe]. For non-specialists I also recommend Witold Rybczynski's City Life as a thoughtful and LUCID introduction to American urbanism, along with a critique of the last few decades of urban "development".
Book Review: Inaccessible, and badly edited
Summary: 1 Stars
Does not contribute much to the discussion, written in a lengthy, self-important, arrogant manner.Book Review: Pompous garbage
Summary: 1 Stars
This book is the most pompous garbage I have ever seen. It is unreadable drivel that has no point and adds nothing to the search for solutions to our urban problems. What were the authors thinking? They deserve the "Emperor has no clothes" award for this trash. Save your money and buy "A Pattern Language," "Edge City," "Changing Places," "Home from Nowhere," or any of many meaningful books that say something relevant.Book Review: Most Important Book on Urban Design Theory Today
Summary: 5 Stars
Colin Rowe proposes a form of inclusive urbanism that meshes the modern city with the traditional city.Book Review: The Theoretical Underpinings of Rowe's Urban Design Studio.
Summary: 5 Stars
Rowe and Koetter's brilliant excursus of urban design theory via the texts and contexts of intellectual history.