 |
Archaeology, History, and Custer's Last Battle: The Little Big Horn Re-examined by Richard Allan Fox Jr.
Book Summary InformationAuthor: Richard Allan Fox Jr. Edition: Paperback Audio: English (Unknown); English (Original Language); English (Published) Published: 1997-09-15 ISBN: 0806129980 Number of pages: 416 Publisher: University of Oklahoma Press
Book Reviews of Archaeology, History, and Custer's Last Battle: The Little Big Horn Re-examinedBook Review: From a Historian . . . Convinced by an Archeologist! Summary: 5 Stars
First, I'm hardly what you would consider a "Custer buff." I've read most of the secondary literature, especially the older material (Stewart, Utley, etc.) and kept up with the debates in the Western history mags. That said, Richard Fox, in my mind, nailed down a case for a new interpretation of the Custer battle, much the way Gerald Posner did with the JFK assassination in "Case Closed."
Much of the book, by the nature of the proof needed, is dry archeology: bullet calibers, spatial analysis, topography, and so on. But surprisingly, Fox really has done his homework in how armies of the day fought. His quick study, early in the book, of cavalry tactics, skirmish lines, and so on, is useful in and of itself, and is not contained in many standard histories of the Custer massacre or cavalry actions in general. Further, his research in the historical sources on men's behavior in war is exceptional. In short, he's pretty good for an archeologist :)
Fox's thesis is that, based on where cartidges and bullet fragments (plus a few metal arrowheads) were recovered, reveals the initial dispositions of Custer's troops. Not only had Custer already divided his forces (the famous Benteen and Reno columns, plus the pack train), but now, preparing to attack the large village, Custer apparently had his forces in two "wings," one of three companies and one of two. While one body of men waited near Calhoun Hill, other companies advanced toward Custer Hill and some of the coulees. A sudden Indian counterattack was briefly stalled by effective fire from the 7th in a skirmish line. But unknown to the troopers, the Sioux and Cheyenne were carefully moving through the gullies and approaching them in large numbers, virtually surrounding them. When the Indian counterattack suddenly materialized, the troopers of the 7th were overwhelmed. Meanwhile, those back on Calhoun Hill sought to link up through Capt. Keough, and as the units disintegrated, the men "bunched" (a typical behavior) and/or retreated to where they thought other units would be. Some of these retreats turned to routs, and the close combat is revealed in the number of cavalry pistol rounds discovered.
Some reviewers here want to label Fox "PC." Nonsense. While I doubt he is a conservative, he seems to give credence to Indian testimony ONLY because it conforms to his thesis, not because they were Indians. Indeed, he disproves some of the Indians' recollections using the same archeological methods. As one of the co-authors of "A Patriot's History of the United States," I don't detect any "PC" mission here. And, as a historian, I appreciate any help archeologists can render.
As to some of the criticisms, while it is true many of the bullets/casings would have been taken by souvenir hunters, that only supports Fox's thesis more, because since it is unlikely souvenir hunters would know whether they were picking up cavalry or Indian rounds, or what type, there would be a randomization in the degradation of the battlefield that would essentially leave the patterns intact. (In other words, it's doubtful someone would say, "I'm going to find all the rounds fired by Private Ryan that day.")
It says nothing of men's courage or even their training that they broke in the face of overwhelming numbers and a fractured command. It is no different than the units that ran at Isandlwana: the "western way of war" depends on training and unit cohesion for its superiority, and when that breaks down, it all comes down to numbers. Custer bears full blame for his poor troop disposition, and for repeatedly dividing his forces despite evidence he was in for the fight of his life.
Summary of Archaeology, History, and Custer's Last Battle: The Little Big Horn Re-examinedOn the afternoon of June 25, 1867, an overwhelming force of Sioux and Cheyenne Indians quickly mounted a savage onslaught against General George Armstrong Custer?s battalion, driving the doomed troopers of the U.S. Seventh Cavalry to a small hill overlooking the Little Bighorn River, where Custer and his men bravely erected their heroic last stand. So goes the myth of the Battle of the Little Bighorn, a myth perpetuated and reinforced for over 100 years. In truth, however, "Custer?s Last Stand" was neither the last of the fighting nor a stand. Using innovative and standard archaeological techniques, combined with historical documents and Indian eyewitness accounts, Richard Allan Fox, Jr. vividly replays this battle in astonishing detail. Through bullets, spent cartridges, and other material data, Fox identifies combat positions and tracks soldiers and Indians across the Battlefield. Guided by the history beneath our feet, and listening to the previously ignored Indian testimonies, Fox reveals scenes of panic and collapse and, ultimately, a story of the Custer battle quite different from the fatalistic versions of history. According to the author, the five companies of the Seventh Cavalry entered the fray in good order, following planned strategies and displaying tactical stability. It was the sudden disintegration of this cohesion that caused the troopers? defeat. The end came quickly, unexpectedly, and largely amid terror and disarray. Archaeological evidences show that there was no determined fighting and little firearm resistance. The last soldiers to be killed had rushed from Custer Hill.
|
 |
Sending My Heart Back Across the Years: Tradition and Innovation in Native American Autobiographyby Hertha Dawn Wong Oxford University Press, USA; Published: 1992-03-12; Hardcover; BookBest price: $84.99Price in other shops: $110.00
The Indian Peoples of Eastern America: A Documentary History of the SexesOxford University Press, USA; Published: 1981-01-08; Paperback; BookBest price: $30.00Price in other shops: $39.95
Consciousness Regained: Chapters in the Development of Mind (Oxford Paperback Reference)by Nicholas Humphrey Oxford University Press, USA; Published: 1984-11-29; Paperback; BookPrice in other shops: $7.95
Native North American Art (Oxford History of Art)by Janet Catherine Berlo, Ruth B. Phillips Oxford University Press, USA; Published: 1998-12-24; Hardcover; BookBest price: $157.48
Congressional Record (Bound Volumes): Volume 153, Part 27Congress; Published: 2011-06; Hardcover; BookBest price: $187.29Price in other shops: $222.00
The Lakota Way: Stories and Lessons for Living (Compass)by Joseph M. Marshall III Penguin (Non-Classics); Published: 2002-10-29; Paperback; BookBest price: $8.52Price in other shops: $15.00
Aztecs of Mexico: Origin, Rise, and Fall of the Aztec Nation (Pelican)by George C. Vaillant Penguin (Non-Classics); Published: 1955-06-30; Mass Market Paperback; BookPrice in other shops: $6.95
The Horner Site: The Type Site of the Cody Cultural Complex (Studies in Archaeology)by George C. Frison Academic Pr; Published: 1987-05; Hardcover; BookPrice in other shops: $110.00
Native Heritage: Personal Accounts by American Indians, 1790 to the PresentMacmillan General Reference; Published: 1995-07; Paperback; BookBest price: $3.25Price in other shops: $15.00
Warpaths: Invasions of North Americaby Ian K. Steele Oxford University Press, USA; Published: 1995-02-02; Paperback; BookBest price: $29.85Price in other shops: $39.95
|
|