 |
A River Runs Through It and Other Stories, Twenty-fifth Anniversary Edition by Norman Maclean
Book Summary InformationAuthor: Norman Maclean Edition: Paperback Audio: English (Original Language); English (Unknown); English (Published) Format: Special Edition Published: 2001-10-01 ISBN: 0226500667 Number of pages: 239 Publisher: University Of Chicago Press
Book Reviews of A River Runs Through It and Other Stories, Twenty-fifth Anniversary EditionBook Review: Fly Fishermen, Pimps, & Card Sharks: Three Interesting Stories Summary: 3 Stars"A River Runs Through It & Other Stories" contains three stories recounting Norman Maclean's life in Montana's Rocky Mountains during the 1920s and 1930s. The book is similar to most collections of short fiction in that the quality of the stories varies. Though there is much to like in this collection, this reviewer is not quite as impressed as most of Amazon's reviewers seem to be.
The best story here is "A River Runs Through It." Ostensibly, the story focuses on the fly-fishing exploits of a father and his two sons. The "real" story is a long meditation on life and loss. Maclean explores how difficult it is to know others as deeply as we might like to know them, even (and especially) those we love the most. The prose is often simple, but elegant: "Now nearly all those I loved and did not understand when I was young are dead, but I still reach out to them" (p. 113). Though I thought that the story went into far too many details about fly fishing, "A River" is a winner.
The second story, "Logging and Pimping," concerns a man Maclean knew who worked as a logger during the summers and as a pimp during the winters. A common theme in Maclean's stories is the varied roles that we all play in our lives. This story is surprisingly weak, given its subject matter; I just didn't find it particularly interesting.
The final story, "USFS 1919" concerns Maclean's work as a fire lookout in the Rockies; the story focuses on how Maclean and his fellow workers "broke camp" at the end of the summer and went into town, where they attempted to make a killing in a card game. I thought that this story was "pretty good"; it is too long and a bit unfocused, but it describes a great adventure and contains some very strong writing.
In the end, Maclean's writing is strong enough to hold anyone's interest. But "A River" will be a favorite only for those readers who have a strong interest in the culture of the rugged outdoorsmen who lived in the Rocky Mountains during the 1920s and 1930s.
Summary of A River Runs Through It and Other Stories, Twenty-fifth Anniversary EditionJust as Norman Maclean writes at the end of "A River Runs through It" that he is "haunted by waters," so have readers been haunted by his novella. A retired English professor who began writing fiction at the age of 70, Maclean produced what is now recognized as one of the classic American stories of the twentieth century. Originally published in 1976, A River Runs through It and Other Stories now celebrates its twenty-fifth anniversary, marked by this new edition that includes a foreword by Annie Proulx.
Maclean grew up in the western Rocky Mountains in the first decades of the twentieth century. As a young man he worked many summers in logging camps and for the United States Forest Service. The two novellas and short story in this collection are based on his own experiences-the experiences of a young man who found that life was only a step from art in its structures and beauty. The beauty he found was in reality, and so he leaves a careful record of what it was like to work in the woods when it was still a world of horse and hand and foot, without power saws, "cats," or four-wheel drives. Populated with drunks, loggers, card sharks, and whores, and set in the small towns and surrounding trout streams and mountains of western Montana, the stories concern themselves with the complexities of fly fishing, logging, fighting forest fires, playing cribbage, and being a husband, a son, and a father.
By turns raunchy, poignant, caustic, and elegiac, these are superb tales which express, in Maclean's own words, "a little of the love I have for the earth as it goes by." A first offering from a 70-year-old writer, the basis of a top-grossing movie, and the first original fiction published by the University of Chicago Press, A River Runs through It and Other Stories has sold more than a million copies. As Proulx writes in her foreword to this new edition, "In 1990 Norman Maclean died in body, but for hundreds of thousands of readers he will live as long as fish swim and books are made."
"Altogether beautiful in the power of its feeling. . . . As beautiful as anything in Thoreau or Hemingway."-Alfred Kazin, Chicago Tribune Book World
"It is an enchanted tale. . . . I have read the story three times now, and each time it seems fuller."- Roger Sale, New York Review of Books
"Maclean's book-acerbic, laconic, deadpan-rings out of a rich American tradition that includes Mark Twain, Kin Hubbard, Richard Bissell, Jean Shepherd, and Nelson Algren. I love its sound."-James R. Frakes, New York Times Book Review
"The title novella is the prize. . . . Something unique and marvelous: a story that is at once an evocation of nature's miracles and realities and a probing of human mysteries. Wise, witty, wonderful, Maclean spins his tales, casts his flies, fishes the rivers and the woods for what he remembers from his youth in the Rockies."-Publishers Weekly
"Ostensibly a 'fishing story,' 'A River Runs through It' is really an autobiographical elegy that captivates readers who have never held a fly rod in their hand. In it the art of casting a fly becomes a ritual of grace, a metaphor for man's attempt to move into nature."-Andrew Rosenheim, The Independent
|
 |