A Respectable Trade by Philippa Gregory
|
List Price: Our Price: $4.25 You Save: $11.75 (73%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $0.01 (click here) Category: Book See more book details and other editions |
|---|
Book Reviews of A Respectable Trade
Book Review: Good but not Great!
Summary: 3 Stars
This book was rich in detail but was really lacking in some areas. I continually lost interest and was not convinced at the reality of the characters in the story. I have read many other books written by Phillipa and have thoroughly enjoyed them. I was unable to put down many of her books about the Boleyn girls and the Virgin Lover was great too. I felt like this book could have been half as long and would have been complete....try Phillipa's other books, they are great!Book Review: Plot is not well established
Summary: 3 Stars
I thought that the details of this book were wonderful but unfortunately the relationship between the two main characters is not well established and therefore a bit confusing. All of a sudden the two characters are involved when the last we heard he thought she was ugly and strange. And her fear turns to passion in an instant leaving the reader feeling left out of the relationship's development.Book Review: Disappointing
Summary: 2 Stars
I am a huge fan of The Other Boleyn Girl, which really brought that particular period in British history and the people who populated it to life. This is the second Gregory book I have read and it was a real letdown.
At times, this book is a gripping read. I found it profoundly chilling the way the characters would casually discuss the slave trade as if they were talking about bales of cotton. This is when the book is at its very best. Every time Josiah, Sarah, and Frances would talk business, I could feel myself almost physically recoiling at the very disturbing way in which they talked about slavery. The beginning of the book was especially strong in this respect and Gregory did a masterful job of capturing the point of view of the average white slave trader of the time. Their dehumanizing view of the Africans they were forcing into bondage was so profound that they actually believed that they were not dealing with people. It made me nearly physically ill to think that there actually were people of this mindset, people who could torture and abuse and commit horrific acts against other people and think nothing of it. It is a chilling period in history. Unfortunately, the masterful handling of this issue is not enough to save the book. The one-dimensional stock characters and unbelieveable love story bog the story down and detract from the central theme of the inherent wrongness of the slave trade.
Mehuru was a particularly disappointing character for me. He is more stereotype than human. His purpose couldn't be more clear had Gregory written him as having the word "dignity" tattooed across his forehead. Yet, in spite of his high principles, he falls madly in love with the woman who owns him, even though there is no apparent reason for it. A man who loves his country as much as Mehuru does, who despises slavery as much as he does, who is as offended at the dehumanization as he was seems to me to hardly be the type of man to find a woman such as Frances very tempting. While it does make sense that he would see some similarities between his situation and hers, it doesn't make sense to me that people who come from such different backgrounds and who have such profoundly different experiences in life would find much common ground. Moreover, Frances does little to nothing to protect Mehuru.
As for Frances, she's simply boring. She is a stock character, plainly put. Her role is to be the genteel woman left without means who doesn't want to become a burden to her wealthier, titled relatives. There is much to pity in someone in such a position but Frances does little more than become pale and grave. Jane Eyre she is not. Even as she comes to realize how disgusting slavery is and even as she falls in love with Mehuru, she does precious little to voice her convictions. She is too weak and too mealy-mouthed to appeal as a character and her reasons for falling in love with Mehuru are borderline offensive. I found it hard to buy the idea that she passionately loved him when it seemed more that she liked the idea of being the one in control rather than being the one controlled.
The other thing I found disturbing was the naming of the slaves. Mehuru and Kbara are the only two given African names. Frances's giving them Christian names is cast in an offensive light and yet the female slaves are from that point on referred to by their Christian names by the narrator, as are the children. It seemed like they were being written off, as if because they weren't central to the story it wasn't worth the bother of giving them African names.
Lastly, the Coles were a tremendous letdown. Josiah is there merely to be an obstacle to Frances's love for Mehuru. Sarah is a character who could have been very interesting and multifaceted had she been handled well. She has every reason in the world for feeling the anger and resentment she feels but she is relegated to the role of shrew. In my opinion, she could have been the best character in the book but instead she is rendered so unlikable that even her most legitimate complaints come across as purely annoying. Had she been portrayed in a more human light, it would have made her attitude toward the slaves all the more chilling.
In summary, Gregory's grasp of history is superb and she obviously put a lot of time and effort into her research. It's a shame that her limp characters detract so severely from that work.
Book Review: Very sad...but ultimately, silly
Summary: 2 Stars
As an African-American woman, I found parts of this book absolutely painful to read. I was alternately in tears and furiously angry at Gregory's unflinching portrayal of the horrors of the slave trade and the racist attitudes of those who profited from it. I knew there could be no "happy ending" in which the slave trade did not continue, and I was sad to note that some racist attitudes are still prevalent today. As a result, I almost did not finish the book.
However, the book quickly segued into a regular old Harlequin romance - improbable at best, and as one previous reviewer noted, with far too many loose ends. I finished it, and learned from it, but I was only entertained by it in the most eye-rolling of ways.
Book Review: A waste of time...
Summary: 2 Stars
I really enjoyed 'The Other Boleyn Sister' and was anxious to read more from the author. This book was a waste of time! I was more than half-way through the book when I realized I didn't care what happened to any of the characters and that most of the book wasn't even logical. For instance, the lead slave seemed to learn to speak English AND write in two chapters, the love affair between the lead slave and Frances was not even a little bit believable, not to mention the 'secret'pregnancy. I can't believe this is the same author. I will try to read other books from Ms. Gregory, but I would not recommend this one to anyone.