A Farewell To Arms by Ernest Hemingway
|
List Price: Our Price: $3.69 You Save: $11.31 (75%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $0.02 (click here) Category: Book See more book details and other editions |
|---|
Book Reviews of A Farewell To Arms
Book Review: Profound. Sad. Moving.
Summary: 4 Stars
I admit I am but a fledgling Hemingway reader..
Definitely not yet an aficianado of the canon!
There are times when I still falter over his simplistic style, his reporter-like, almost point-form and unembellished narration. His pithy dialogue which seems at times so unusual that I am jarred into the realization that I am holding a book in my hands.
But this book, A Farewell To Arms was a fantastic read and has given me a new appreciation, I guess, for Hemingwayism in general.
Genre-wise, it is somewhat of a historical romance, perhaps.
Set squarely in WWI Italy and Switzerland. Lots of war, lots of rain, lots of gore, lots of pain.
I hesitate from saying too much about the novel, story-wise, because truly there are many ways that one could ruin it, by saying too much, especially as regards its increasingly-paced and unforgettably moving final sections. [The novel is broken down into five parts, books, or sections].
For me as a reader, one of the key things [feelings] I am left with is an overwhelming sense of the simultaneous dual-existence of meaninglessness and meaningfulness. I feel that this is a theme or thread running the length of the novel.
There is the meaninglessnes of war. The seemingly arbitrary way that beautiful things can be so quickly taken from us, be they dignity, or love, or life itself. The suddenness of bone-crunching shrapnel in the midst of friendly camaraderie... bombs putting an end to meaningful conversation. War is a perpetual mess, needing to be cleaned up.
But alongside this "meaninglessness" [what I am calling meaninglessness for lack of a better term], Hemingway paints a searing portrait of love and the meaningfulness of intimate relationship.
Lt. Henry's [solidly requited] love for the Scottish nurse Catherine Barkley is like flashes of color thrown into the clattering frames of a black-and-white newsreel. It was meaningfulness, inserted into mayhem.
It was something beautiful, growing, thriving and enduring in a field of ugliness, disaster and loss.
The novel ended with the tears of two men.
Lt. Henry's.
And mine.
I could say so much more about #74 on the list of the 100 Best Books of All Time, but I won't.
I will simply ask a question and then answer it:
In A Farewell To Arms, does Hemingway show us that the meaningfulness of love and goodness and hopes and dreams are altogether something too good to be true?
No.
He shows us that all of these things are too good, and true!
Book Review: one of the awful-lest books...
Summary: 1 Stars
I will put a qualifier up front on this review - I listened to this book on tape. I think the reader's expression of dialogue particularly just exacerbated my annoyance with this book. I originally tried to read it, but I found the run-on sentences nearly impossible to endure.
I really wanted to understand the value and meaning of this book as others have clearly found, but I could not... I found the characters shallow, Baby. I don't know why Catherine and Frederic fell in love.
The dialogue was ridiculous, Darling. It was neither grand nor spendid. The speech patterns, using the same words over and over (p. 134, "We were all cooked... cooked...cooked........"), and also Catherine consistently flip-flopping (me paraphrasing and exaggerating... I hate the rain. It scares me. I love it.) made me want to bang my head against the wall.
As I said, I wanted to "get" this book and appreciate Hemingway, but I came away thinking he wasn't a very good writer and this wasn't even a very good book.
Book Review: __Underscore.
Summary: 5 Stars
What beauty. What excellent prose. There is little I can say that has not already been said about Hemingway's style. So, I will keep my review short and blunt. This is one of the select few finest American literary works of the twentieth century. If you have any interest in Hemingway's writing, this novel is a must-read. Book Review: A good, quick read
Summary: 4 Stars
The great American novelist doesn't disappoint.
Jake, a likable but disabled incarnation of a rather classic Hemingway character, struggles as an impotent in a love square for the affections of the quasi-royal Lady Ashley.
Set primarily in Spain during Fiesta, Hemingway's portrayal of decadence, overconsumption, and the breakdown of Judeo-Christian values in post-WWI Europe makes for a hard to put down story. And unlike some of Hemingway's other works, it doesn't leave the reader feeling like hell at the end.
Book Review: Why is this a classic?
Summary: 2 Stars
I enjoy "the classics" and have read most of Hemingways works. This isn't up to par of the others and I would skip it. I had to force myself to read it.